User avatar
The Eldritch Rain Eldritchness @rain@an.eldritch.gift
2y
I'm like, of course BG3 is the new standard for CRPGs, why would it not be? It is bloody amazing!

1
1
0
0
1
User avatar
RinguPingu @RinguPingu@masto.ai
2y
@rain Because setting impossibly high standards for games is unhealthy for the industry ​:sadturtle:​
1
0
0
0
User avatar
The Eldritch Rain Eldritchness @rain@an.eldritch.gift
2y
@RinguPingu I dunno, I feel like high standards should be placed on games from the giants in the industry.
1
0
0
0
User avatar
RinguPingu @RinguPingu@masto.ai
2y
@rain Expecting games of high quality is not the same as expecting something like BG3. BG3 took 6-ish years to develop for a team of ~400 people (not including outsourcing partners), who were working with the specialized tools and knowledge to make this exact game from having developed Divinity: Original Sin and it's sequel (plus their respective Definitive Editions).
The game is the product of a perfect storm of development circumstances that most devs can only dream of.
1
0
0
0
User avatar
The Eldritch Rain Eldritchness @rain@an.eldritch.gift
2y
@RinguPingu Hmm, maybe you're right! I mean, having BG3 as a standard is a little bit unfair when the giants can't even hit DivOS2 levels of quality.
1
0
0
0

User avatar
RinguPingu @RinguPingu@masto.ai
2y
@rain this Twitter thread goes into some detail about what I described (and is where I took the gist of this argument from), it's worth a read:
twitter.com/WritNelson/status/1677632079792668673
1
0
0
0
User avatar
The Eldritch Rain Eldritchness @rain@an.eldritch.gift
2y
@RinguPingu I mean, that thread essentially asks for the bar not to be raised. Regardless of wants though, the bar has been raised, at least in the minds of consumers. I don't think it is unreasonable to ask for high quality, when most RPGs from larger studios seem mediocre at best.
2
0
0
0
User avatar
The Eldritch Rain Eldritchness @rain@an.eldritch.gift
2y
0
0
0
0
User avatar
RinguPingu @RinguPingu@masto.ai
2y
@rain The thread is asking that people understand that BG3 was made under favourable circumstances, and that it's unreasonable to expect every RPG that comes out from now on to meet that same level.

That is, unless you're willing to accept that every RPG needs to take 6-7 years (not including the time required to develop the tools) to develop for 400 people (not including the outsourcing partners). Then yeah, let BG3 be the standard I guess.
1
0
0
0
User avatar
The Eldritch Rain Eldritchness @rain@an.eldritch.gift
2y
@RinguPingu Indeed!
0
0
0
0